Coffin Corner: Reaching Beyond the Limitations
The bearer of an ominous name, coffin corner sounds eerily spooky, but it need not be. The airplane behaviors within coffin corner are all governed by several known aerodynamic factors. Once the interaction between these factors is explained and understood, coffin corner becomes much more predictable and navigable for the skilled pilot.
What is the Coffin Corner?
In Advisory Circular 61-107B, the FAA defines Coffin Corner, or Q-Corner, as it is officially named, as “a term used to describe operations at high altitudes where low IAS yield high TAS (as indicated by Mach number) at high angles of attack (AOA).”
Essentially, the term “coffin corner” identifies the upper limits of an aircraft’s operational envelope when flying at high altitudes (above 25,000 feet). These limits are also referred to as the aerodynamic ceiling and are where stall and overspeed meet. Since this particular type of aerodynamic ceiling is located at very high altitudes, it is encountered by jet pilots, rather than pilots of small general aviation aircraft.
What makes Coffin Corner dangerous?
It is difficult to maintain steady straight and level flight in coffin corner because the margins are very small. An aircraft must stay within a narrow speed range and avoid reaching beyond the limitations because flying too fast or too slow will cause the plane to stall. The only way to fly in coffin corner is to maintain a steady true airspeed (TAS) within the narrow parameters which continue to narrow further with higher altitude.
Aerodynamics in Coffin Corner
The two key variables that set up the aerodynamics of coffin corner are true air speed (TAS) and altitude. These variables can be plotted out on a graph with the horizontal x-axis being the true air speed (TAS) and the vertical y-axis representing altitude.
Remember that while an aircraft will stall at a constant indicated airspeed (IAS), as altitude increases and air density decreases, the true airspeed (TAS) will increase, and the plane will have a higher TAS stall speed or true stall speed. The plotted line of the Vs or true stall speed makes up the left side of our coffin corner graph.
The speed of sound varies with temperature and gets slower at colder temperatures. This means that higher altitudes with their colder temperatures translate to a slower speed of sound or mach speed. The plotted line on the right side of the coffin corner graph depicts the maximum mach speed the plane can operate at.
As our graph shows, the narrow operating envelope of coffin corner exists in the peak of the graphed pyramid, bordered on one side by the stall limit and on the other side by the mach limit. Flying too slow, a pilot encounters low speed buffeting and reaches the stall limit. Flying too fast will result in reaching the mach limit and encountering a high-speed buffet which again causes airflow separation on the wings and ends in a stall.
While most pilots are familiar with the aerodynamics of a low speed buffet or stall, the high-speed buffet and mach limit may be less familiar to some. Aircraft have a speed known as Mach crit or M crit. At this speed, the air over at least one part of the airfoil (usually the top of the wings) is reaching supersonic speeds. The shock wave generated by the supersonic speeds creates airflow separation and drag. The center of lift also shifts back making the nose of the aircraft want to pitch down as it approaches M crit. The speed just below this is the Mmo or maximum mach operating speed and that speed is just within the right side of our coffin corner pyramid.
Visual learners can benefit from PilotEd’s coffin corner video that helps explain the concept and illustrate the graph. Learn more about coffin corner and other high-altitude flying phenomenon in Fly the Wing.
- PilotMall.com Editor